Sloppy Science

ScienceDo you ever get surprised by unintended lessons?  Sometimes those are the ones that are best remembered.

I’ve been working with my three science classes on the Problem-based lesson I created this summer at the Eighth Floor.  It’s gone well, and students have progressed in their understanding of the Scientific Method as hoped.  We’re more than halfway through this nearly three-week unit, and Friday’s classes performed the lab experiments they’d designed.  I hadn’t initially planned to do labs until Monday, but by Thursday it was clear the groups were ready.

On Friday we were late starting first hour because of a faculty meeting that ran a little long.  But students burst into the classroom asking, “Are we doing labs today?”  I said I wasn’t sure we’d have time because of the late start, the word root quiz we do every Friday, and the daily discussion board question they were required to complete.   “Oh, please.  We’ll hurry.”  They rushed other students who were still getting settled.  “Hurry up!” they admonished their classmates.  “We’re going to do labs!”

What science teacher could resist such eagerness?  I know I can’t.  I’d prepared the classroom’s lab table with beakers, test tubes, triple beam balance, stirring rods, pipets, acid, assorted antacids for testing and other lab equipment they’d requested.  The table was so full, in fact, that as soon as students turned in their quizzes, they grabbed supplies off the lab table and brought them to their work tables where there was more room.  I didn’t realize it yet, but this was the beginning of a sharp detour.

Before I could finish helping one group into their lab coats and goggles, the other one had two types of antacid powder ground in the mortar (which was which??), acid measured into test tubes, and a pad of pH paper was already lost.  It was all I could do in the next thirty minutes to keep up with bringing paper towels to sop up overflowing  Alka Seltzer, spillreminding students to record observations and data, and repeating, “What’s your procedure say?” when they asked what they should do next.  When the acid-antacid mixture from one student’s shaken test tube splashed out onto the books and laptop on the table, my head nearly exploded.

There will be plenty to reconstruct on Monday when we attempt to reflect on the labs and analyze what the results tell us.  I was disappointed on Friday that in their enthusiasm, students had hydrochloric acid and antacid powders sloshed all over the tables.  Their technique was terrible!  And it seemed they missed the point of the lab entirely.  But the truth is that real scientists do a lot of sloppy work on the way to profound discoveries.  I should know; I’ve done some pretty sloppy science in my day.  I hope to take advantage of this situation to drive that point home.

flasksStudents too often feel they’re not allowed to make mistakes in class.  They don’t want to look foolish by being “wrong.”  But some lab experiments cry out for do-overs, and I think this one qualifies.  It’s a detour from my unit plan, but a great opportunity to stress neatness and precision in mixing and measuring chemicals.

I’m insisting they work at the lab tables next time; we’ve had enough chemical spills to last the year.  The up side?  Now I won’t have to explain (again) why eating is forbidden in my classroom.

7 thoughts on “Sloppy Science

  1. It reminds me of parenting. Sometimes you have to bite your tongue and let them make mistakes. At least when the stakes are small. I’m still trying to learn that lesson!

  2. Janice would you be willing to share you lesson with me? I am “preaching” the Scientific Method right now! They are struggling a little.

    • Hi Shelena! I just read the article about your PBL work on the OK SDE site today. Good job! I’ll have to dig this lesson out from last year. We’re a 1 to 1 school so most everything was posted on the class website and included discussion board posts and group wikis, but you could probably revise. Since I also teach pregnant and parenting teen girls, the “problem” we were solving was heartburn during pregnancy. Students designed labs to compare effectiveness of antacids that are safe to use during pregnancy. I’ll see what I can find and email it to you. It’s good to hear from you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s